8/15/09

THE LEGALITY OF EXCLUDING FIJI FROM PACER-PLUS DISCUSSIONS

Prof Jane Kelsey LLB(Hons), BCL (Oxon), MPhil (Cantab), PhD

School of Law, University of Auckland

Summary

Article 1 of PACER defines a ‘Party’ to mean a State that has signed and ratified the Agreement pursuant to Article 19. The Republic of the Fiji Islands is such a State. It is therefore a Party to PACER.


It should be presumed, in the absence of provisions to the contrary, that decisions under PACER are to be made in accordance with the convention of the Forum, being by consensus. That would require the participation of Fiji.


In any case, a process or decision under PACER that involves all parties to the agreement collectively must include Fiji. There is nothing in PACER to suggest that any implied power to suspend a Party from its rights and obligations under PACER was intended.


There are three routes by which a decision to launch free trade negotiations under PACER might lawfully be made:


(i) Commencement of negotiations in 2011 as agreed in Article 5. There is nothing in Article 5:1 (or the rest of the treaty) that entitles any Party to PACER or any group of such Parties to exclude any other Party to PACER from those collective negotiations, although a Party may elect to do so by withdrawing from the agreement.


(ii) If a PIC Party to PACER commences negotiations on a free trade agreement in goods with a non-PACER Party, it may trigger earlier consultations with a view to negotiations as soon as practicable. There are two relevant triggers:


Ø In Article 6:3 this applies to individual countries. Any such obligation is strongest in relation to Fiji and PNG, which have initialed (but not signed or ratified) the Interim EPA on trade in goods. It ceases to apply to individual FICs whose negotiations have concluded without an agreement.


Ø Article 6:4 applies where all the Parties to PICTA jointly commence such negotiations and requires collective action by PICTA Parties under PACER. Fiji is a Party to PICTA. Any collective action required of PICTA Parties, especially relating to the EPA goods negotiations with the EU, must include Fiji.


(iii) Agreement to launch negotiations before 2011 following a general review of PACER under Article 16:2. Article 16:3 states that one purpose of a review of PACER is to make decisions on the opening and timetabling of negotiations for economic integration agreements or arrangements. This provision must refer to a general review, unless a general review transferred that power to another forum. General reviews involve all Parties collectively. A Party cannot be arbitrarily excluded from the conduct of such a general review, or decisions as to its form or timing, or as to the transfer of any exercise of its functions.


A general review is distinct from an annual review by Parties to PACER of ‘the implementation and operation of the agreement and all aspects of trade and economic cooperation’ under Article 16:1. The Government of Fiji as a Party to PACER is entitled to attend this annual review. The annual review of PACER is distinct from the Forum Trade Ministers’ Meeting and may be held at the FTMM of or otherwise.


The exclusion of Fiji from either an annual or general review on the grounds that Fiji’s participation in the FTMM has been suspended cannot be justified. There is an implied obligation on the Parties to PACER to convene such meetings at a time and place from which no Party is excluded. Failure to do so would render decisions taken at such meetings open to legal challenge.


It is important to stress that Article 17 formally assigns to the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat certain administrative and clerical functions under PACER that are separate from the responsibilities that it performs under its legal personality as the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat. The suspension of Fiji from the Forum cannot affect the responsibilities of the Forum Secretariat in relation to Fiji under PACER.


What are the implications of this argument for the validity of any decision to launch the negotiation of ‘PACER-Plus’? The Parties, convened as the Pacific Island Forum Leaders, agreed in Niue last year on ‘the need for officials to formulate a detailed road map on PACER Plus, with the view to Leaders agreeing at the 2009 Forum to the commencement of Negotiations.’ However, no decision to commence those negotiations has been taken.


That decision is being sought by Australia and New Zealand at the Forum Leaders’ Meeting in Cairns in August 2009. The Leaders’ decision is largely contingent on a decision of the Trade Ministers of the Parties to PACER in Apia on 18 and 19 June 2009. That decision is intended to take place within the Forum Trade Ministers’ Meeting. The Government of Fiji has been excluded from both those meetings.


This opinion concludes that it is not lawful for the Parties to PACER other than Fiji to convene for their annual review, or to make a decision to launch negotiations under PACER, in the absence of the Government of Fiji.


The only way to proceed with the forthcoming meetings or to make decisions regarding PACER-Plus negotiations in a manner that is consistent with PACER, in the absence of the Government of Fiji, would be if:


(a) Fiji has consented. There is no evidence of such consent; or


(b) the PACER text has been amended to legitimize the exclusion of a Party to the agreement from activities in which it would otherwise be entitled to participate. Article 18 requires unanimous agreement of the Parties to any amendment to the text. Fiji’s exclusion from participation makes that impossible per se. Fiji would presumably veto any such amendment if its agreement were sought.


If the Government of Fiji considers that the actions of other Parties to PACER have breached its rights under the agreement it can notify them, through the Forum Secretariat, of its wish to enter consultations. The other Parties must respond in good faith and as soon as possible, with a view to seeking a mutually satisfactory solution.


THE LEGALITY OF EXCLUDING FIJI FROM

PACER-PLUS DISCUSSIONS


Prof Jane Kelsey LLB(Hons), BCL (Oxon), MPhil (Cantab), PhD

School of Law, University of Auckland


This legal opinion is provided for the Pacific Network on Globalisation PANG).

FIJI’S STATUS IN THE FORUM

Fiji was ‘suspended from full participation in the Forum’ as of 2 May 2009 on the terms agreed by the Forum Leaders in Port Moresby on 27 January 2009.


Participation ‘by the leader, ministers and officials of Fiji from all Forum meetings and events arranged by the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat, including the annual Pacific Islands Forum Leaders Meeting’ was suspended indefinitely.


The Chair of the Forum made it clear that Fiji was not being expelled from the Forum and that the Republic of Fiji remains a member of the Forum group of nations.


FIJI’S STATUS UNDER PACER


Article 1 of PACER provides a number of relevant definitions:


‘Party’ means a State that has signed and ratified the Agreement pursuant to Article 19. The Republic of the Fiji Islands is such a State. It is therefore a Party to PACER.

‘Forum Island Countries’ are explicitly defined to include the Fiji Islands.

‘Forum’ means the Pacific Islands Forum, as referred to in the agreement establishing the PIFS. As noted above, suspension from participation is not expulsion. Fiji remains a member of the Forum.


DECISION MAKING PROCESSES UNDER PACER


Article 16 sets out the institutional mechanisms for decision-making under PACER, but it does not specify the rules for making decisions.


It should be presumed, in the absence of provisions to the contrary, that decisions under PACER would be made according to the convention of the Forum, being by consensus. That would require the participation of Fiji.


That interpretation is consistent with the requirement under Article 18 that any amendment to PACER can only be made by unanimous agreement of the Parties. The exclusion of Fiji would be a de facto amendment to the treaty to which it has not agreed.


Even if the requirement for consensus in general under PACER was doubted, any process or decision that involves all parties to the agreement collectively must include Fiji.


It might be argued that an activity involving or decision by ‘all parties’ means all parties present and voting or participating in an attempt to reach a consensus, and that a decision in the absence of Fiji would still be valid. However, United Nations’ precedents to that effect involve situations where a state has voluntarily absented itself from a meeting or decision, not the exclusion of a party from the process without its consent.


There is nothing in PACER to suggest that any implied power to suspend a Party was intended.


THE ROLE OF THE FORUM SECRETARIAT


In Article 17 the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat is formally assigned the responsibility to provide secretariat services for PACER and other international agreements established pursuant to it.


The Secretariat is performing administrative and clerical functions under PACER that are separate from the responsibilities that it performs under its legal personality as the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat. The suspension of Fiji from the Forum cannot affect the responsibilities of the Forum Secretariat in relation to Fiji under PACER.


Its functions are articulated in Article 17:2, as being a repository and conduit of communications and the provision of administrative and technical support services.


The Forum Secretariat has no other role in relation to PACER. Any direction of the Parties to the Secretariat requiring it to perform other functions would need to involve all the Parties, unless one or more Parties has voluntary absented itself from making such a decision.


The Secretariat cannot therefore act in any way that denies Fiji access to PACER meetings or decisions, or the right to send or receive communications among PACER Parties.


PROCESSES FOR A DECISION TO LAUNCH PACER-PLUS NEGOTIATIONS


There are three routes by which a decision to launch negotiations under PACER might lawfully be made:

1. A pre-commitment to negotiations in 2011 under Article 5;


2. ‘Triggering’ consultations with a view to negotiations before 2011 under Article 6;


3. Agreement to launch negotiations before 2011 following a general review of PACER under Article 16.


It is not clear which of these is currently being relied on, but it seems likely to be the third.


1. A Pre-commitment to begin negotiations in 2011 (Article 5)


Article 5:1 is a pre-commitment among the parties, including Fiji, collectively to enter into collective negotiations with a view to establishing reciprocal free trade arrangements between the Forum Island Countries (including Fiji) and Australia and New Zealand.


Such negotiations must be entered into eight years after PICTA came into force, i.e. 2011, unless earlier agreed under Article 16 or triggered by the provisions of Article 6.


There is nothing in Article 5:1 (or the rest of the treaty) that entitles any Party to PACER or any group of such Parties to exclude any other Party to PACER from those collective negotiations.


[Article 5:2 allows any party to PACER (eg Australia or NZ) to notify the Forum Secretariat that it wants to enter consultations with a view to negotiating the terms and conditions of new trading and economic integration arrangements. Whether or not Australia or NZ has formally notified the Secretariat under this provision, there is no corresponding obligation on any Parties who receive such notification to respond. It seems likely that any such notification would inform discussions under Article 16.]


2. Triggering of negotiations before 2011 (Article 6)


It might be argued that the process of consultations with a view to commencement of negotiations with Australia and NZ before 2001 has been triggered by the action of the FICs in two ways. It is important to note that these triggers relate to negotiations with non-PACER countries for a free trade agreement in goods.


Ø Article 6:3: an individual FIC that is party to PACER begins formal negotiations for a free trade agreement in goods with one or more developed non-Forum countries.


The trigger activates the obligation to ‘offer to undertake consultations with a view to commencement of negotiations free trade arrangements’ with Australia and/or New Zealand ‘as soon as practicable’.


Any reliance on this provision is strongest in relation to the two Parties that have initialed the Interim EPA on trade in goods, being Fiji and PNG.


This obligation is on each individual FIC Party to PACER that has commenced negotiations with an external developed country. It does not presume collective negotiations, as are currently under discussion.


The Article 6:3 obligation ceases, pursuant to Article 6:9, if the negotiations with the non-Forum country are discontinued without an agreement on trade in goods being reached. It is arguable that Article 6:3 no longer applies to the majority of FICs who have not signed the interim EPA on trade in goods and indicated that they do not intend to do so.


Ø Article 6:4: all the Parties to PICTA jointly commence negotiations for a free trade agreement with a non-Forum country.


This trigger involves a collective action by all the Parties to PICTA. Fiji is a Party to PICTA.


When, and even whether, formal negotiations a free trade in goods agreement with the EU commenced is disputed. However, it is certainly arguable that all the Parties to PICTA, organized as the PACP states, did jointly commence such negotiations.


A number of PACP states appear to have since discontinued their participation in the goods EPA, which would remove any obligation under this paragraph. That seems to contradict the purpose of this trigger, which is to entitle Australia and NZ to negotiations where all PICTA Parties have negotiated an agreement on goods. Whatever, that situation does not apply to Fiji.


Assuming that the triggering has been activated, the obligation under this paragraph is for the PICTA Parties collectively to offer to undertake consultations, as soon as practical, with Australia and New Zealand, individually or separately.


The words ‘individually or separately’ must be read as referring only to the consultations with Australia and/or New Zealand, given identical wording in paragraph 3, which refers to an offer of negotiations by an individual FIC, and the joint action by PICTA parties that triggers this obligation.


Again, any collective action required of PICTA Parties, especially relating to the EPA goods negotiations with the EU, must include Fiji.


3. A General Review of PACER (Article 16)


Article 5 states that negotiations with a view to establishing reciprocal free trade arrangements between the FICs and Australia and NZ may be agreed to earlier than 2011 as part of a general review under paragraph 2 of Article 16.


Article 16 provides for two different kinds of reviews of PACER.


Article 16:1 provides for an annual review by Parties to PACER of the implementation and operation of the agreement and all aspects of trade and economic cooperation.


This annual review may take place at the annual meeting of the Forum Trade Ministers or ‘otherwise as appropriate’.


The meeting of PACER Parties is clearly distinct from the Forum Trade Ministers’ Meeting and could be held in a different form, time or place.


The Republic of Fiji is a Party to PACER and is entitled to attend this meeting. The exclusion of Fiji from the annual review of PACER on the grounds that Fiji’s participation in the FTMM has been suspended cannot be justified.


There is an implicit obligation on the other Parties to PACER to convene an annual meeting from which no Party is excluded. Failure to do so would render decisions taken at such a meeting open to legal challenge.


Article 16:2 mandates a general review of the operation of PACER no later than three years after it enters into force, and every subsequent three years, unless otherwise agreed by the Parties.


‘Otherwise agreed’ relates to the conduct of a general review at three yearly intervals. The wording is ambiguous. It could relate to agreement to conduct a general review of PACER otherwise than through three yearly reviews; or that the frequency may not be every three years. Whichever, it still refers to the conduct of a general review.


Paragraph 2 refers to all Parties collectively. This does not justify the exclusion of any Party from the conduct of the general review or decisions as to its form or timing.


As argued previously, it must be assumed that decisions under Article 16:2 are made by consensus in the absence of any contrary intention. Fiji is therefore entitled to be present at and participate in the conduct of any general review, in any decision on any agreed alternative to a general review, and in any such alternative process.


Article 5 explicitly states that the decision to launch negotiations earlier than 2011 would be made as part of a general review under Article 16:2, not an annual review under Article 16:1.


As Fiji is entitled to participate in the activities mandated under paragraph 2, it is entitled to participate in any decision to launch negotiations.


Article 16:3 refers generically to ‘the reviews’, whereas paragraphs 1 and 2 distinguish between annual reviews and three yearly general reviews.


One of the purposes of ‘the reviews’ specified in paragraph 3 is to make decisions on the opening and timetabling of negotiations for economic integration agreements or arrangements. This cannot override the explicit intention of Article 5 that a decision to begin negotiations prior to 2011 must be made at a general review conducted either three yearly as otherwise agreed.


The Parties, convened as the Pacific Island Forum Leaders, agreed in Niue last year on ‘the need for officials to formulate a detailed road map on PACER Plus, with the view to Leaders agreeing at the 2009 Forum to the commencement of Negotiations.’


No decision to commence those negotiations has been taken. That decision is being sought by Australia and New Zealand at the Forum Leaders’ Meeting in Cairns in August 2009.


The Leaders’ decision is largely contingent on a decision of the Trade Ministers of the Parties to PACER in Apia on 18 and 19 June 2009. That decision is intended to take place within the Forum Trade Ministers’ Meeting.


The Government of Fiji has been excluded from both those meetings.


CONCLUSION

It is not lawful for the Parties to PACER other than Fiji to convene for their annual review, or to make a decision to launch negotiations under PACER, in the absence of the Government of Fiji.


If Fiji considers that the actions of other Parties to PACER have breached its rights under the agreement it can notify them, through the Forum Secretariat, of its wish to enter consultations. The other Parties must do so in good faith and as soon as possible, with a view to seeking a mutually satisfactory solution.


The only way to proceed with the forthcoming meetings or to make decisions regarding PACER-Plus negotiations in a manner that is consistent with PACER, in the absence of the Government of Fiji, would be if:


(a) Fiji has consented. There is no evidence of such consent; or


(b) the PACER text has been amended to legitimize the exclusion of a Party to the agreement from activities in which it would otherwise be entitled to participate. Article 18 requires unanimous agreement of the Parties to any amendment to the text. Fiji’s exclusion from participation makes that impossible per se; and Fiji would presumably veto any such amendment if its agreement were sought.

8 June 2009

8/14/09

Tuvalu - Islands on the frontline of Climate Change

Tuvalu - Islands on the frontline of Climate Change from panos pictures on Vimeo.

With photography by Robin Hammond of Panos Pictures, this multimedia piece looks at the island nation of Tuvalu, as the Tuvaluan people become some of the first environmental refugees, a direct result of man-made climate change.



In December this year a treaty to replace the Kyoto protocol will be drawn up at the climate change conference in Copenhagen. At a preliminary summit in March, scientists presented new information that revised previous estimates of future sea level rise. The new figures suggest that by the end of the century the oceans could be one metre or more above their current levels. Coastal regions will be flooded and low-lying nations such as the tiny South Pacific country of Tuvalu could be submerged.



The impact of rising seas and the increase in extreme weather events can already be seen in Tuvalu. It is one of 22 Pacific island nations with 7 million inhabitants between them that contribute only 0.06% of global greenhouse gas emissions but are three times more vulnerable to climate change than countries in the North.



At the primary school in Funafuti, children are taught about climate change from the age of six. They are also learning what it means to emigrate, because this could be the last generation of children to grow up in Tuvalu. Its people are already in flight. More than 4,000 live in New Zealand, and the Tuvaluan government is planning the migration of the remaining 10,000.





See also: Pacific Islanders call for justice on climate and human rights

8/9/09

Collateral Damage: Atomic Testing in the Marshall Islands



Between 1946 and 1958, the U.S. detonated 67 nuclear devices in and around the Marshall Islands. The impact of these tests on the Marshallese people was profound - in terms of both actual radioactive exposure and the displacement of people from their home islands due to contamination.

Racism in Australia



News report released November 2008.
thnx 2


TransitionFilmSydney

La Ho'iho'i Ea 7-26-09 JAMZ



Mahalo Nui
ponosize

8/8/09

Opinion piece for the International Day of the World's Indigenous Peoples

by Navanethem Pillay
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights


More than a symbolic celebration


The estimated 370 million indigenous peoples need and deserve more than just symbolic celebrations on 9 August, when they commemorate everywhere the International Day devoted to the reaffirmation of the value and resilience of indigenous life and cultures. After centuries of repression, they need comprehensive tools to defend their human rights, their way of life, and their aspirations.

One such tool is the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Among other provisions, the Declaration emphasized human rights principles of equality and non-discrimination for indigenous peoples. It established their right to self-determination and to maintain and strengthen their distinct political, legal, economic, social and cultural institutions, while retaining their right to participate fully in public life. Crucially, this document underscored indigenous peoples’ right to preserve or freely dispose of and trade their traditional lands and resources.

Following negotiations that spanned more than two decades, the Declaration was adopted in September 2007 by the General Assembly with the support of 143 member states. This support keeps expanding. Significantly, Australia and Columbia—two of the countries that originally did not approve the text—have now endorsed the Declaration. These developments are encouraging, but we must continue to strive for universal acceptance of this crucial document.

Such acceptance is key to counter the daily hardship and discrimination that indigenous peoples endure. It is estimated that at least one in every ten indigenous peoples in the world is facing extreme poverty. These peoples are more likely to receive inadequate health services and poor education—if any at all. Economic development plans often bypass them or do not take into sufficient consideration their particular needs and traditions. Other decision-making processes are often equally contemptuous of or indifferent to their contribution and customs. As a result, laws and policies designed by majorities with little regard to indigenous concerns frequently lead to land disputes and conflicts over natural resources that threaten the way of life and very survival of indigenous peoples.

We must step up our common efforts to make the Declaration something more than a mere pledge of intent. We must translate its letter and spirit into concrete change, change that can be felt in indigenous peoples’ daily life.

In line with the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and other human rights instruments, States, indigenous peoples, the United Nations system and others concerned must join their efforts and reach solutions based on true dialogue, mutual understanding, tolerance and respect for human rights.

I am confident that giving indigenous peoples a true voice and say in decision-making would benefit not only them, but also our whole societies, as we look for answers to address major challenges. Consider, for example, the impact of climate change. Indigenous peoples, such as indigenous reindeer herders in the Arctic or the pastoralist Maasai community in East Africa, face the risk of bearing the brunt of climate change. But their cultures, experience and knowledge of the environment can—and ought to—provide solutions to address this and other common global threats. When we defend indigenous peoples’ rights in the face of land grabs and expropriation, we are also likely to protect biodiversity. This is evident in places, such as the Amazon region, where sustainable forestry methods mastered by indigenous peoples can help to address the serious problem of deforestation.

Ways to promote indigenous peoples’ rights in policy development and their participation in public life must be found primarily at the national level. But governments can also benefit from the human rights expertise, legislative savvy and advocacy of UN human rights mechanisms, as well as contributions from civil society. These partners in indigenous rights can help refine reforms according to international standards and make indigenous peoples’ concerns resonate at the international level. These mechanisms include the Permanent Forum of Indigenous Issues, which gathers hundreds of indigenous representatives annually, and the Special Rapporteur on Indigenous Peoples, who has helped to advance their human rights in a range of country situations. In addition, the UN Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples is tasked to formulate advice on their entitlement to education, a key theme for indigenous peoples around the world.

There is still a long way to go. No doubt the road ahead will be bumpy. But let us work together to move the principles of the Declaration from paper into practice. We need to act now to ensure that indigenous peoples live in dignity and prosper. They have waited a long time. They expect nothing less.
- - -

8/6/09

Imprisoned People and Social Justice Forum




The forum will bring together formerly imprisoned people and their family members, advocates, lawyers, activists and interested community members, to discuss and workshop effective measures and strategies for social justice for imprisoned people, and a reduction in rates of recidivism. The forum will have a strong focus on Indigenous women’s experiences of the
criminal justice system.

Speakers include Rachel Herzing, (Creative Interventions, USA), Cassandra Shaylor (Critical Resistance, USA), Kim Pate (Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies, Canada), Debbie Kilroy (Sisters Inside, QLD), Antoinette Braybrook (Aboriginal Family Violence Prevention Legal Service, VIC), Vicki Roach (human rights advocate and activist, VIC), and other men
and women with the lived experience of imprisonment.

Who Should Attend? Organisers of this forum are prioritising involvement from people most impacted by imprisonment and related issues; men and women who have been imprisoned or their family members, Indigenous people, culturally and linguistically diverse community members, consumers of the mental health system, and others.

About FVPLS Victoria, CHRIP and Flat Out: FVPLS Victoria was established in October 2002 to provide assistance to victims of family violence and sexual assault and to work with families and communities affected by violence. Flat Out has been in operation since 1988 and is a state wide
service that provides housing and re-integration support to women leaving prison. CHRIP is a project of Flat Out that aims to build the capacity of organisations that provide advocacy and support to prisoners, and establish a dedicated Prisoners’ Legal Service in Victoria.



Please find a flier and registration form attached, numbers are limited so
interested people should RSVP as soon as possible.


On the evening of the forum (Thursday 10th September) we will be holding a
celebration evening with a film screening, prisoner art show, and music.
More details to come.

7/17/09

Prisoner amnesty urged

MEDIA RELEASE 16 July 2009

Prison Reform Group of Western Australia

Attorney General Christian Porter should give consideration to a prisoner amnesty similar to
that proposed by New Zealand’s Chief Justice as a way to stem the rising prison population.

Dame Sian Elias, who’s had more than 40 years in the criminal justice field, recently told the
NZ Law Society that she accepts “retribution is a proper response for serious crime” but
that “all the evidence and informed opinions seem to point to the futility of believing that
the causes of crime can be addressed by penal policy and the criminal justice process…
Penal policy is largely irrelevant to reduction of crime and making our communities safest”.

Citing a cost of $100,000 a year for keeping an offender in prison versus $10.04 for
maintaining someone on a community based sentence (NZ figures) Dame Sian went on to
say that “reducing sentence levels would reduce the prison population, not only by cutting
the length of prison terms but also by bringing more sentences within the bounds set for
community-based sanctions, including home detention”.

Suggesting the use of “direct tools to manage the prison population”, Dame Sian noted that
“other countries use executive amnesties to send prisoners into the community early to
prevent overcrowding.

“If we are not prepared to relax the pressures to contain risk in the discretionary decisions
as to bail and parole, the only other immediate options may be to confront the length of
sentence (effecting an overall reduction in sentence)… and early release amnesty,’ Dame
Sian concluded.

This is a view endorsed strongly by WA’s Prison Reform Group, which today called on Mr
Porter to give consideration to an executive amnesty for all prisoners with less than six
months left to serve on their sentences and for all women currently held in the Boronia pre-
release facility.

“Such a move would release the immediate pressure on WA’s overcrowded prisons,” noted
Group spokesperson Rex Widerstrom. “It would free up places at Boronia for women
currently held at Bandyup, and at the various low-security prisons and prison farms for male
prisoners confined in high security at Casuarina, Hakea and similar facilities.

“While it is the government’s duty to do what it can to prevent crime, as Dame Sian notes
the length of sentences actually has little or no effect on community safety.

“So against Mr Porter’s desire to be seen to take a vote-winning stance as ‘tough on law ‘n’
order’ must be balanced the huge social costs of being unable to build hospitals and schools
whilst the money is spent on more prisons.

“Many governments have provided amnesty at the lower end of the security scale without
incurring some sort of ‘rising tide of crime’ on their streets,” Mr Widerstrom noted. “We’re
not talking about releasing violent criminals who’ve done little or no rehabilitative work in
prison. We’re focusing the call for an amnesty on low security prisoners with exemplary
behaviour records whilst in prison, with six months or less to serve.

“The Attorney General clearly likes to be perceived as taking a tough stance on crime.
Tough it may be, but it’s clearly not effective” (see figures below).


ENDS

The March quarter 2009 national average daily imprisonment rate was 167 prisoners per
100,000 adult population. Western Australia reported a rate of 241 per 100,000 adults. And
that figure is rising, not falling, despite the present government’s stance.

Western Australia First Thursday July 2009 First Thursday July 2008
Total in prison 4419 3780
Sentenced 3711 2998
Remand 689 761
Aboriginal & TSI 1787 (40.4%) 1551
Women 341 275

Total in Juvenile Detention 144 166
Sentenced 84 79
Un-sentenced 60 87
Aboriginal & TSI 112 (77.8%) 125 (75.3%)
Young Indigenous 104 males 8 females
Young non-Indigenous 29 males 3 females

Contact: Rex Widerstrom 0400 133 854
or: Dr Brian Steels 0419 907 016

Link to original story (including a downloadable copy of Dame Sian’s speech):

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10584828

7/16/09

ANTI INTERVENTION PROTEST FROM MP JENNY MACKLINS OFFICE TO CENTRELINK


Anti Northern Territory Intervention protest moves from Minister Jenny Macklin's Electorate office in Heidleberg, Victoria round the corner to the Centrelink office where Barbara Shaw from Mt Nancy Town Camp, Alice Springs in the Northern Territory is unable to access her low income due to the racially discriminatory welfare quarantining of Aboriginal Peoples' income in the NT.

SOS Students of Sustainability demonstrate with Barbara Shaw in support of Aboriginal Peoples living under the racist NT Intervention.

Victorian police brutality breaks up the non violent protest in Centrelink ...

Contact:
wgar.info
rollbacktheintervention.wordpress.com
Stoptheintervention.org

7/13/09

Voices from the frontline: Pacific Islands speakers tour

During July hear first hand accounts of the impacts of climate change on our Pacific neighbours. Oxfam and Greenpeace have combined to bring local leaders from the Pacific nations of Tuvalu, Kiribati and the Federated States of Micronesia (FSM) to Australia for a series of public meetings.


"The future of Kiribati is in our hands - we work very hard each year to support and help students to be successsful. But what is the future of our children when our country is being threatened by global warming?"

– Pelenise Alofa Pilitati, a speaker on the tour from Kiribati


All three of these low-lying island states are in grave danger from climate change. Sea level rise, tidal surges, salination of crops and fresh water, coral bleaching and loss of fisheries are already affecting these countries. Some Pacific islanders have also been forced to relocate because of climate change.

The realities of climate change in the Pacific underscore the urgent need for a global agreement on climate change. It is not too late to ensure that the Pacific has a future. To do this the Australian government must take strong action and commit to cut greenhouse emissions by 40% by 2020. To assist the Pacific and other developing nations to deal with the unavoidable effects of climate change the Australian government must commit to pay our fair share into a UN fund to assist developing nations cut their emissions and adapt to climate change.

Dates and Venues

Sydney
When: Thursday 23 July, 7 – 8.30pm (registration from 6.30pm)
Where: Mitchell Theatre, Sydney Mechanics School of Arts, 280 Pitt St, Sydney
Speakers: Reverend Tafue Lusama and Pelenise Alofa Pilitati

Brisbane
When: Tuesday 28 July, 6.30 – 8 pm (registration from 6pm)
Where: Brisbane City Hall, Brisbane Room
Speakers: Marstella Jack, Reverend Tafue Lusama, Pelenise Alofa Pilitati, Sam Reuben (Torres Strait Islands) and John Kris (Chair, Torres Strait Regional Authority)

Melbourne
When: Thursday 30 July, 6.30 – 8pm
Where: Melbourne Town Hall, Supper Room
Speakers: Marstella Jack, Reverend Tafue Lusama and Pelenise Alofa Pilitati

Cairns
When: Sunday 2 August, 4 - 5.30pm
Where: TBC

Other climate change talks

Solving the Climate Crisis Talk
When: Saturday, 25th July, 1pm
Where: Theatre G, Australian Museum, 6 College St, Sydney
Speakers: John Hepburn and Pelenise Alofa Pilitati
The talk is free with general entry to the Museum. General entry is $12 (adults) and $8 (concession).

The Perfect Storm - Australia's role in dealing with the triple crunch of the global financial crisis, climate change and rising food prices
ALP Conference Forum by Oxfam Australia and the Centre for Policy Development
When: Friday 31 July, 6 – 7.30pm
Where: Sussex Room, Crowne Plaza, 150 Day Street, Darling Harbour, Sydney
Speakers: Sharan Burrow, Andrew Hewett, Reverend Tafue Lusama, Ian Dunlop and Ben McNeil

The speakers

Pelenise Alofa Pilitati - Chairperson Church Education Director's Association in Kiribati (CEDAK), Managing Director, Kauaoki Foundation Enterprise, Kiribati

Pelenise says that climate change is about survival for the people of Kiribati. "The future of Kiribati is in our hands - we work very hard each year to support and help students to be successsful. But what is the future of our children when our country is being threatened by global warming?"

Reverend Tafue Lusama - Chairperson Tuvula Climate Action Network, Program Secretary Church of Tuvalu Dept Peace and Justice, Pastor, Christian Church of Tuvalu.

Tuvalu has already seen significant internal relocation of citizens as a result of climate change and could be the first nation in the world to disappear because of rising sea levels. Reverend Tafue is a compelling advocate for action on climate change.

Marstella Jack - Former Attorney General, Federated States of Micronesia

Marstella has recently returned from the United Nations Intersessional meeting on climate change that took place in Bonn. She is acutely aware of why these global negotiations are so important for Pacific nations.


How you can help

source: http://www.oxfam.org.au/campaigns/climate-change/take-action/pacific-speakers-tour/

We hope that these series of community forums will generate enough public support and media interests, leading up to the Pacific Islands Heads of Government Meeting in Cairns (Australia) in August, 2009.

Please forward this to your friends and networks.
Thank you for your support

6/18/09

Trade Winds to Blow Pacific Away


Self Determination Not Invasion, Get Up Stand Up for Indigenous Rights

On Saturday 20th June supporters of Aboriginal rights in Melbourne will be marking the two-year anniversary of the Northern Territory intervention with a solidarity rally in the CBD, Featuring speakers: Gary Foley, Robbie Thorpe, Aletha Penrith an Alice Springs town camp resident, + others. Performers: local Indigenous hip hop artists Little G, Mr Morgz, Alter Egoz, and Tjimba and the Yung Warriors.

Nathan Lovett-Murray, founder of Payback Records, has organized local Indigenous hip hop artists to perform at the rally. “Little G, Mr Morgz, Alter Egoz, and Tjimba and the Yung Warriors will be at the rally raising their voices against the discriminatory policies of the government, and in support of Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory having control over their lives,” said Nathan.


“We have organized the rally in order to show our disgust and opposition to the Rudd Government’s expansion of Howard’s racist intervention policy, and to stand in solidarity with the Indigenous people of this country. We will also be holding a public meeting as an opportunity for people to learn more about the effects of the NT intervention and the direction the Rudd Government is taking it, the meeting will also involve workshops and planning for the campaign. The governments attempt to take Aboriginal land, close homelands, and wind-back hard-won Aboriginal self determination will not be ignored here in Melbourne.

“The Rudd Government’s approach to Indigenous people is dominated by hypocrisy and blackmail! With one hand they sign the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous people, and with the other they refuse to re-instate the Racial Discrimination Act, instead expanding the policies of the intervention and forcing Indigenous people to give up their land in return for desperately needed housing and services,” said Marisol Salinas from the Melbourne Anti-Intervention Collective

Rallies are also being on the 20th of June @:

Darwin 11am Raintree Park
Sydney 10:30am Belmore Park
Brisbane 11am Queen's Park
Perth 12 noon Wesley Church
Adelaide 12 noon Parliament House

See Also:


6/14/09

PALESTINE & US HEGEMONY




Exploring the achievements of resistance and discussing shifts in US foreign policy


6pm, Thursday July 9th

Friend Meeting House, Euston

Speakers:

HIZBULLAH REPRESENTATIVE

(video link from Lebanon)

HAIFA ZANGANA

(on Iraq)

DR AZZAM TAMIMI

(on Palestine)

NADINE ROSA-ROSSO

(from recogniseresistance.net, on the role of the anti-imperialist movements in the West)

DYAB ABOU JAHJAH

(IUPFP International Director, video link from Lebanon)

JOHN REES

(from Stop the War, on the role of the anti-war movement)

Chair: Sukant Chandan (Chairman of the British section of the IUPFP)

Following from Obama’s historic speech in Cairo on June 5th, this meeting will discuss the following issues:

* How has the Palestinian, Iraqi and Lebanese resistance

impacted on US plans for world hegemony?

* Is the US in strategic retreat?

* What does the Obama phenomenon mean for the peoples of the South?

Organised by the British section of the

International Union of Parliamentarians for Palestine

http://iupfp.org/

Contact:

07709 112 126

sukant.chandan@gmail.com

6/11/09

Aboriginal Rights Solidarity Rally & Public Meeting





On Saturday 20th June supporters of Aboriginal rights in Melbourne will be marking the two-year anniversary of the Northern Territory intervention with a solidarity rally in the CBD, Featuring speakers: Gary Foley, Robbie Thorpe, Aletha Penrith an Alice Springs town camp resident, + others. Performers: local Indigenous hip hop artists Little G, Mr Morgz, Alter Egoz, and Tjimba and the Yung Warriors.


Nathan Lovett-Murray, founder of Payback Records, has organized local Indigenous hip hop artists to perform at the rally. “Little G, Mr Morgz, Alter Egoz, and Tjimba and the Yung Warriors will be at the rally raising their voices against the discriminatory policies of the government, and in support of Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory having control over their lives,” said Nathan.


“We have organized the rally in order to show our disgust and opposition to the Rudd Government’s expansion of Howard’s racist intervention policy, and to stand in solidarity with the Indigenous people of this country. We will also be holding a public meeting as an opportunity for people to learn more about the effects of the NT intervention and the direction the Rudd Government is taking it, the meeting will also involve workshops and planning for the campaign. The governments attempt to take Aboriginalland, close homelands, and wind-back hard-won Aboriginal self determination will not be ignored here in Melbourne” said Joe Lorback from the Melbourne Anti-Intervention Collective.


“The Rudd Government’s approach to Indigenous people is dominated by hypocrisy and blackmail! With one hand they sign the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous people, and with the other they refuse to re-instate the Racial Discrimination Act, instead expanding the policies of the intervention and forcing Indigenous people to give up their land in return for desperately needed housing and services,” said Marisol Salinas from the Melbourne Anti-Intervention Collective

“Jenny Macklin’s treatment of Alice Springs town camp residents is absolutely disgraceful. She has smeared Aboriginal run organizations, such as Tangentyere Council, in an attempt to take the land and control from them. Rather then acknowledging the fact that the lack of housing and infrastructure in the town camps is due to a complete lack of funding, she is instead giving total control over the town camps to the Northern Territory Government which has continually failed them” said James Brennan from the Melbourne Anti-Intervention Collective



The Solidarity Rally will take place on Saturday 20th June at 12pm in the State Library The public meeting also on Saturday will be at 3pm at Trades Hall Meeting Room 1.

Rallies are also being on the 20th of June @:

Darwin 11am Raintree Park
Sydney 10:30am Belmore Park
Brisbane 11am Queen's Park
Perth 12 noon Wesley Church